Tesla Model Y Performance goes head-to-head against a Porsche Cayenne EV to see if it is really worth the extra cost
Published on Nov 07, 2026 at 7:03 PM (UTC-5)
by Ben Thompson
Last updated on Nov 07, 2026 at 7:03 PM (UTC-5)
Edited by
Mason Jones
This YouTuber pitted a Tesla Model Y Performance against a Porsche Cayenne EV to see how they compared.
Everyday Chris knows his stuff when it comes to EVs.
So which one would he end up preferring when it came time to compare a Tesla Model Y Performance to a Porsche Cayenne?
Would the extra cost of the Cayenne be justified?
Who is Everyday Chris?
Everyday Chris is consistently covering EVs, whether it’s breaking down the costs of Tesla ownership or giving a brutally honest review of the Cybertruck.
But in a recent video, he was bringing in an EV from another brand.
He was putting the Porsche Cayenne up against the Tesla Model Y Performance to see which one came out on top.
Why was he comparing the Tesla Model Y Performance to a Porsche Cayenne?
The most blatant differences between these two EVs was the cost.
“Would you rather have four Teslas or one Porsche? I fully configured this Porsche Cayenne Electric. It was around $260,000,” he said.
For the sake of this comparison, Chris was going to look at three areas – how the cars drive, how comfortable they are, and which is easiest to live with.
Which car was better to drive?
The Tesla had a lot going for it on the driving front – 0-60 in 3.3 seconds, with 306 miles of range.
It handled well and felt tight, and Full Self-Driving was always a welcome perk.
However, the Porsche Cayenne had a few tricks up its sleeve.
“The Porsche Cayenne EV can do something you would never expect from a performance EV. It can actually offroad,” Chris said.
Capable of reaching 60mph in 4.5 seconds, with a range of 317 miles, the Cayenne has the Model Y beat on most metrics.
While Tesla may have an inch over on it on autonomy, the Cayenne ultimately triumphed in this category.
“For driving, Porsche wins hands down. It just drives so well,” Chris concluded.
“Not only does it feel so connected to the ground and road, it can even off-road.”
When it came to comfort, which of these EVs had the edge?
When it comes to comfort, both cars offer up different experiences on their interior.
The Tesla has heated and ventilated seats to its credit, alongside an extendable thigh bolster.
As for the Cayenne, it’s 18-way lumbar support, but there was one big perk for Chris, who is 6’3″ – extra head space.
“I’ve never had this much head space in a car before,” he said.
In general, it just had more options too, from climate controls to an ionizing air purifier.
Ultimately, the Cayenne secured this round too.
Which one would be easier to live with?
Both cars come with a frunk, although the Model Y’s is lager.
Chris decided to carry out the ‘luggage test’ in which he filled up the trunks of both cars to see which could carry more.
In this round, the Model Y managed to fit in one extra suitcase on account of its sub-trunk.
In terms of the tech, he also gave the round to Tesla, noting that Porsche’s software was ‘basic, but not bad’.
Tesla’s built-in dashcam, Grok AI, games, and plethora of features had the winning edge for him.
However, the Cayenne won back his favor on the charging front – going from 10 to 80 percent in 16 minutes.
Which one did he end up preferring between the Porsche Cayenne and Tesla Model Y Performance?
There was a lot of different things to mull over, but Chris ultimately concluded that both cars had different strengths.
While the Tesla was great value when it came to school runs and commuting, he felt the Porsche was better for weekend drives.
“If I want to have emotional, spiritual driving, and I want to feel rich and powerful, Porsche Cayenne EV all day, baby,” he concluded.
Was he surprised by how the cars fared in his comparison?
“To be honest, I expected Porsche to come out on top in areas like driving experience, interior and exterior design, and the level of customization available,” he told Supercar Blondie.
“Tesla obviously has the upper hand when it comes to Full Self-Driving and technology, but there were two things about the Cayenne EV that genuinely surprised me: cargo space and charging.
“The cargo space was much better than I expected. The frunk was actually quite useful, and overall, the storage was pretty impressive.
“But the charging was on another level. I’m not sure exactly how Porsche has managed to achieve those charging speeds or what the long-term impact on battery degradation might be, but I was incredibly impressed. The efficiency of the Cayenne EV was also surprisingly good.
“Overall, while it’s certainly an expensive vehicle, I think you get what you pay for. Porsche has done a really impressive job with it!”
The best of Supercar Blondie, every Sunday
The week's best car stories, straight to your inbox. Free.
Ben joined Supercar Blondie in February 2025 after being published by international organizations including LADbible, The Sun, the New York Post, and the Daily Mail. He covers supercars, rare and collectible vehicles, aviation, luxury assets, and the fascinating people behind them. His reporting has explored everything from seven-figure supercars and historic Ferrari collections to unusual aircraft adventures and extraordinary automotive discoveries from around the world. Ben has also gained first-hand insight into vehicle craftsmanship and customization, including visiting specialist workshops to see bespoke vehicles up close.
