Tesla's Optimus robot shuts down after replicating the gesture of its human operator removing their headset

A Tesla Optimus robot falling down during a recent demonstration has ignited a fresh debate over the true level of autonomy in Tesla’s robotics program.

At the ‘Autonomy Visualized’ event in Miami, footage circulating on social media shows the Optimus humanoid tipping over a few water bottles and then collapsing backwards.

Now, some may argue that this isn’t a big deal, especially since new technology generally isn’t perfect.

However, the controversy doesn’t revolve around the fact that the robot fell; instead, it’s all about the way it fell.

SBX CARS – View live supercar auctions powered by Supercar Blondie

Netizens suspect the Optimus robot may not be autonomous

The Tesla Optimus robot was supposed to be showing off its abilities at the Miami event by picking up water bottles.

However, things took a turn when the robot suddenly fell over.

The short clip went viral online, with many netizens sharing it across platforms like Reddit, X, and YouTube.

Many observers who have seen the video note that the falling gesture closely resembles a human removing a VR headset.

This is a hallmark of remote control setups in robotics, leading many to believe that the robot’s fall hints at human involvement.

While falls and balance errors are common in cutting-edge robotics development, the timing and nature of the hand movement in this case have made the incident more than just a typical robotic stumble.

After all, Tesla has previously faced scrutiny over how much of Optimus’s behavior in demos is truly autonomous, versus assisted by humans.

CEO Elon Musk has publicly stressed that Optimus is controlled by AI and not tele-operated.

He even highlighted clips that show the robot performing kung fu moves without human input.

However, past company showcases have acknowledged that humans sometimes aid the robot at events, similar to how early autonomous vehicle demonstrations often relied on safety operators.

Supercar Blondie has reached out to Tesla for comment.

Tesla is going full steam ahead

The Miami incident has also sparked broader discussion about public expectations versus technological reality.

Supporters of Tesla’s robotics efforts say remote control elements can be part of training or hybrid operation systems as AI capabilities continue to improve.

Critics argue the viral clip underscores how far Optimus still has to go before achieving the fully independent, AI-driven autonomy that Tesla has often touted.

In any case, it’s clear that Musk has a lot of faith in Optimus.

After all, he once claimed that Tesla Optimus robots will be responsible for making Tesla a $25 trillion company.

He later doubled down, predicting that the Optimus Gen 2 robot will be the ‘biggest product of all time’.

According to his latest update, Tesla will begin mass production of its robots, with plans to produce 1 million units a year.

Ambitious, but this is very much Elon Musk’s style.

Key milestones achieved by Tesla Optimus

August 2021: Tesla announced the Optimus, with original concept sketches

September 2022: The first walking prototype was revealed

Early 2023: Tesla shared the first videos of the robot performing basic autonomous tasks

December 2023: Optimus Gen 2 was unveiled, promising major improvements in speed, weight, dexterity, and balance

December 2024: Tesla released a video of its Optimus robot walking autonomously on rough terrain

December 2025: Tesla received flak for its robot falling down during a demo, in the same month that it showed great progress in its walking abilities

DISCOVER SBX CARS: The global premium car auction platform powered by Supercar Blondie